Custom Challenge Coins
We believe custom challenge coins are timeless symbols of honor, unity, and achievement that celebrate the people, teams, and traditions they represent.
Custom Challenge Coins — Designed with Meaning, Built to Last
At Design Your Pins, a veteran-owned maker, we know a challenge coin is more than metal. It’s a living tradition born from the U.S. military and carried forward by
police officers, firefighters, EMS teams, veterans, corporate leaders, and community groups who value recognition, camaraderie, and pride.
Our founder—a United States Marine Corps veteran—built this company on the belief that every coin should capture the spirit of the people it represents. Whether you’re creating a coin for a military unit, a first responder department, a nonprofit, or a business milestone, we’ll help you design something unique that becomes part of your history.
- Veteran-owned with deep respect for military and first responder traditions
- Expert design team that transforms your vision into a custom coin
- Premium materials, plating, and finishing options for unmatched quality
- Trusted by military units, government agencies, and organizations nationwide
What Is a Challenge Coin?
A challenge coin is a small, custom-made coin that represents belonging, recognition, and pride. Originating in the United States Armed Forces, these coins are traditionally presented to
service members to honor achievements, strengthen camaraderie, and symbolize unity.
Today, challenge coins are used far beyond the military. Police departments, fire departments, EMS teams, veterans’ organizations, corporate groups, and nonprofits all use them to celebrate milestones, recognize service, and create a lasting token of appreciation.
Whether presented during a ceremony, given as a gift, or carried as a symbol of identity, challenge coins have become a timeless tradition that honors the people and stories behind them.
The History of Challenge Coins
The history of challenge coins is rich with tradition and legend. While the exact origin is debated, most stories trace their beginnings back to the United States military during the early 20th century.
One of the most popular accounts dates to World War I, when an American pilot was captured behind enemy lines. He carried a coin stamped with his squadron’s insignia, which ultimately saved his life and proved his identity to allied forces.
Another story places the roots of challenge coins in the Vietnam War, when U.S. service members carried special unit coins to show loyalty and avoid using live ammunition during “challenges” in base clubs.
Over time, special forces units like the 10th Special Forces Group and even the Office of Strategic Services (OSS) helped popularize the practice. Today, coins are still a proud tradition in the Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps, and Coast Guard, while also being embraced by first responders and civilian organizations worldwide.
The Coin Check Tradition
One of the most unique aspects of challenge coins is the long-standing tradition of the “coin check”. This practice began in military circles and has since spread to many organizations that embrace the challenge coin culture.
A coin check usually starts when a member initiates a challenge by slamming their coin on a table, tapping it on a glass, or simply announcing a challenge. Everyone present must immediately show their own challenge coin. If someone cannot produce theirs, they are responsible for buying the next round of drinks or a set penalty agreed upon by the group.
If everyone can produce their coin, the challenger often becomes the one who buys the round. This tradition not only reinforces the importance of always carrying a coin but also strengthens the sense of unity and belonging among those who share the bond.
Today, coin checks remain a fun and symbolic way to honor the meaning behind challenge coins while keeping the camaraderie alive across military units, first responder groups, and even corporate teams.
Who Uses Challenge Coins Today?
One of the most unique aspects of challenge coins is the long-standing tradition of the “coin check”. This practice began in military circles and has since spread to many organizations that embrace the challenge coin culture.
A coin check usually starts when a member initiates a challenge by slamming their coin on a table, tapping it on a glass, or simply announcing a challenge. Everyone present must immediately show their own challenge coin. If someone cannot produce theirs, they are responsible for buying the next round of drinks or a set penalty agreed upon by the group.
If everyone can produce their coin, the challenger often becomes the one who buys the round. This tradition not only reinforces the importance of always carrying a coin but also strengthens the sense of unity and belonging among those who share the bond.
Today, coin checks remain a fun and symbolic way to honor the meaning behind challenge coins while keeping the camaraderie alive across military units, first responder groups, and even corporate teams.
Customization Options for Your Challenge Coins
One of the reasons custom challenge coins are so popular is the ability to design them exactly how you want. From shapes and sizes to finishes and unique features, every detail can be tailored to tell your story.
Shapes & Sizes
While most challenge coins are round, you can choose from shields, hexagons, dog tags, bottle-cap designs, or completely custom die-cut shapes. Standard sizes range from 1.5” to 2”, but larger or smaller coins can be created for special occasions.
Finishes & Plating
Your coin’s finish adds character and prestige. Options include antique brass, polished gold, silver, black nickel, copper, and dual-tone plating. These finishes not only affect the appearance but also enhance durability.
Design Add-Ons
To make your coin stand out, consider special features such as bottle-opener coins, spinner coins, glow-in-the-dark enamel, 3D sculpting, UV printing, or gemstone inlays. These unique touches elevate your coin into a true keepsake.
Edge Styles
The edge of your coin can make a bold difference. Choose from rope-cut, diamond-cut, reeded, cross-cut, or smooth edges to complement your design.
Color Options
With hard enamel, soft enamel, transparent enamel, and full-color UV printing, you can achieve the perfect look. Whether you want vibrant colors that pop or a subtle antique finish, the right color treatment ensures your coin leaves a lasting impression.
At Design Your Pins, our design team works closely with you to select the best combination of shapes, finishes, and features to bring your vision to life. Every detail is crafted with precision, making your coin both unique and memorable.
Packaging & Presentation
The way you present your custom challenge coins is just as important as the design itself. Proper packaging protects your coins and enhances their impact when they’re given as a gift, award, or token of recognition.
Display Boxes
Elegant velvet boxes or leatherette cases add prestige to any coin, making them ideal for formal presentations and ceremonies.
Acrylic Cases
Clear acrylic coin holders showcase both sides of your coin while protecting it from scratches and handling. Perfect for collectors or long-term display.
Coin Stands
Small, durable coin stands allow recipients to proudly display their coin on a desk, shelf, or mantel. They are a popular option for recognition awards or keepsakes.
Pouches & Sleeves
Affordable and practical, velvet pouches or plastic sleeves provide protection while keeping coins portable. These are great for bulk orders or coins meant to be carried daily.
Whether you choose a premium display box or a simple pouch, the right packaging ensures your coins are memorable, professional, and worthy of the tradition they represent.
Who Uses Challenge Coins Today?
While challenge coins began as a military tradition, their use has grown far beyond the United States Armed Forces. Today, they are embraced by a wide range of groups who value recognition, unity, and pride.
In the military, challenge coins remain a symbol of service, dedication, and honor across all branches — Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps, and Coast Guard. They are often presented by commanders to mark achievements, deployments, or milestones.
First responders such as police departments, fire departments, and EMS teams also carry on the tradition, using coins to recognize bravery, teamwork, and years of service. Many well-known organizations, including the NYPD, proudly issue their own challenge coins.
Beyond military and emergency services, corporate leaders, nonprofits, schools, and community organizations use custom coins to celebrate anniversaries, achievements, fundraising efforts, and team spirit.
No matter the setting, challenge coins continue to serve as a powerful reminder of identity, belonging, and shared purpose.
Presidential & Cultural Challenge Coins
Challenge coins have grown beyond military and first responder traditions to become part of American culture. One of the most recognized examples is the Presidential Challenge Coin, a tradition carried on by U.S. presidents since the 1990s.
The White House Communications Agency (WHCA) often oversees the design and distribution of presidential coins, which are given to diplomats, service members, and honored guests as a symbol of appreciation and respect. These coins are highly collectible and serve as a reminder of the close connection between leadership and those they recognize.
Beyond politics, challenge coins appear in sports teams, corporate events, nonprofit organizations, and popular culture. From commemorating movie premieres to marking milestones at Edwards Air Force Base and other institutions, coins continue to represent identity, loyalty, and accomplishment across society.
This broad cultural adoption shows that challenge coins are more than tradition —
they’re a universal way to celebrate achievement and honor meaningful connections.
Why Choose Us for Your Custom Challenge Coins
At Design Your Pins, we bring tradition, craftsmanship, and personal service together to create custom challenge coins that stand out. As a veteran-owned company, we understand the history, pride, and meaning behind every coin, and we treat each design with the respect it deserves.
Veteran-Owned Expertise
Our founder is a United States Marine Corps veteran who built this company on the values of honor, integrity, and excellence. That background ensures every coin we make reflects the same attention to detail and respect for tradition.
Quality Craftsmanship
We use only the highest-quality materials, plating, and finishes to deliver coins that are durable, precise, and visually striking. From antique brass and gold plating to custom edges and enamel colors, your coin will be made to last.
Personalized Design Support
Our in-house design team works with you step-by-step to bring your ideas to life. Whether you have a detailed sketch or just a concept, we’ll turn it into a professional, production-ready design at no extra cost.
Trusted by Organizations Nationwide
From military units and first responder departments to corporate teams and nonprofits, we’ve proudly created coins that honor achievements, celebrate milestones, and strengthen bonds across the country.
When you choose Design Your Pins, you’re not just ordering coins — you’re investing in a tradition of excellence and a token that will be cherished for years to come.
Why Choose Design Your Pins?
What are challenge coins used for?
How does the “coin check” tradition work?
Can I order challenge coins for non-military groups?
Absolutely. Today, challenge coins are popular with first responders, corporate teams, schools, nonprofits, and community groups in addition to the military.
What is the minimum order size?
Most custom coin orders start at 50 coins, but we can work with you to meet your project’s needs. Larger orders often receive volume discounts
How do I start designing my custom challenge coin?
Begin by reaching out to our team with your idea, whether it’s a detailed design or a concept. Our design experts will guide you through the process, using our AI Custom Design Tool or direct collaboration to refine your vision.
Do presidents really have challenge coins?
Yes. Since the 1990s, U.S. presidents have created Presidential Challenge Coins, often distributed by the White House Communications Agency (WHCA). These are given to service members, diplomats, and honored guests.
Is there a minimum order quantity?
How long does it take to produce custom challenge coins?
The production time can vary based on the complexity of the design and order size. Generally, it takes about 2-4 weeks from design approval to shipment.
Can I see a sample before placing a full order?
Absolutely. We can provide digital proofs and, in some cases, physical samples to ensure your design is perfect before full production begins.
What is your return policy?
Due to the custom nature of our products, all sales are final. However, we stand behind the quality of our work and will address any concerns related to manufacturing defects.
If you have more questions or are ready to start your custom challenge coin project, contact us today. We’re here to help bring your vision to life.
Because your cause matters.
We placed an order to have some pins made and they are top notch! They’re prefect in every way! Thank you for the quality of workmanship!
My experience was outstanding from start to finish. The web site was excellent, the follow-up emails were extremely helpful and responsive. They made certain that I got exactly what I wanted and needed. My order arrived earlier than expected and was of excellent quality. I would very happily recommend to anyone ordering pins.
Apleasure to work with every step of the order process, ensuring my company was taken care of. If we need pins/nametags again, I know exactly where I will go.
